Destination Comparisons
Our detailed guides compare beaches, hotels, dining, activities, costs, and more to help you choose the perfect coastal getaway.
Amelia Island vs St Augustine
Florida's barrier island paradise versus America's oldest city. Compare beaches, history, crowds, and which destination suits your vacation style.
Read Comparison →Amelia Island vs Jekyll Island
Two neighboring Sea Islands with different personalities. Compare beaches, golf, Gilded Age history, and which barrier island is your perfect escape.
Read Comparison →Amelia Island vs St Simons Island
Quiet elegance meets vibrant village life. Compare nightlife, beaches, family activities, and discover which Golden Isle suits your travel style.
Read Comparison →Amelia Island vs Hilton Head
Two premier resort islands in the Southeast. Compare golf, beaches, dining, shopping, and find out which upscale coastal retreat is right for you.
Read Comparison →Why Use Our Comparisons?
We've visited these destinations and created honest, detailed guides to help you make the best choice.
Side-by-Side Tables
Quick comparison tables covering beaches, hotels, dining, activities, and costs so you can see the differences at a glance.
Honest Recommendations
We tell you which destination wins in each category and give clear "Choose X if..." verdicts based on your travel style.
Local Insights
Insider tips on the best times to visit, hidden gems, and practical advice you won't find in generic travel guides.
More Comparisons Coming Soon
We're constantly adding new destination comparisons. Here's what's in the works:
Amelia Island vs Sanibel Island
Two of Florida's most beloved barrier islands compared
Coming SoonIs Amelia Island Expensive?
Complete cost breakdown and budget tips
Coming SoonIs Amelia Island Worth Visiting?
Honest assessment for first-time visitors
Coming SoonHotels vs Vacation Rentals
Which accommodation type is right for you?
Coming SoonNorth End vs South End
Compare the two sides of Amelia Island
Coming SoonBest for Families vs Couples
Which areas and hotels suit your group?
Coming SoonFrequently Asked Questions
What makes Amelia Island different from other Florida beaches?
Amelia Island is Florida's northernmost barrier island with 13 miles of uncrowded beaches, rare Appalachian quartz sand, the only beach horseback riding in Florida state parks, and a 50-block Victorian historic district. It's also the only U.S. location to have been under 8 different flags.
Can I visit multiple destinations on one trip?
Absolutely! Jekyll Island and St Simons Island are both under an hour from Amelia Island—perfect for day trips. St Augustine is about an hour south. Many visitors base themselves on Amelia Island and explore the region.
Which destination is most affordable?
Jekyll Island tends to be the most budget-friendly with affordable golf and fewer luxury properties. St Augustine offers good mid-range options. Amelia Island and Hilton Head have more luxury resorts but also have budget-friendly chain hotels.
Which is best for families with kids?
All of these destinations are family-friendly! Amelia Island offers resort kids' programs (Omni, Ritz-Carlton) and nature activities. St Simons has Neptune Park with playground, pool, and mini golf. Jekyll Island has the Sea Turtle Center. St Augustine has Castillo de San Marcos and the Alligator Farm.
Ready to Experience Amelia Island?
Now that you've compared the options, start planning your perfect Amelia Island getaway.