Overview
Looking for an honest review of Amelia Hotel at the Beach? We've analyzed hundreds of guest reviews and compiled everything you need to know before booking. From room quality to dining options, here's our complete guide to help you decide if this resort is right for your Amelia Island getaway.
Amelia Hotel at the Beach is one of Amelia Island's premier resort destinations, offering beachfront access, multiple dining venues, and full-service amenities. Located on the southern end of the island, guests enjoy a more secluded experience while still being within easy reach of historic downtown Fernandina Beach.
Best For
- Families – Multiple pools, kids programs, and spacious rooms
- Golf enthusiasts – On-site championship courses
- Couples seeking relaxation – Full-service spa and quiet beach areas
- Conference attendees – Extensive meeting facilities
Pros & Cons
Based on our analysis of guest reviews, here's what visitors consistently love and what to be aware of:
✅ What Guests Love
- Stunning ocean views and beautiful beach access
- Excellent pool service and amenities
- Friendly, attentive staff throughout the resort
- Great dining options on property
- Nearby "Neighborhood Village" with shops and restaurants
⚠️ Things to Consider
- Rooms showing some age in places
- Premium pricing, especially during peak season
- Large resort can feel crowded during events
- Some noise from neighboring rooms reported
- Golf course renovations may affect experience
📅 Check Current Rates at Amelia Hotel at the Beach
Compare prices across top booking sites to find the best deal
What Guests Are Saying
Here's a selection of recent guest reviews to give you a feel for the experience:
"THE WORST HOTEL EXPERIENCE I’VE EVER HAD! I booked a last-minute reservation about three hours before arriving. When I checked in, the room I had reserved online was not available — they gave me a completely different room. I initially agreed, which I acknowledge, but the moment I walked in, I knew I couldn’t stay there. The room smelled strongly like a hospital, the bathroom was filthy, an..."
"My stay at this hotel was extremely disappointing. The room I received was not the one I booked, and the condition of the space did not meet even basic standards of cleanliness or comfort. I chose to leave shortly after checking in because it did not feel sanitary or safe."
"I love the fact that it is not a corporate hotel. It is very quaint & charming, plus it is in a great location. But - the WiFi was a huge issue. I was not able to sign into work to complete some projects which was a major issue. Even after buying a booster it still did not work. Other than that, everything else was great. 😊 I would definitely stay here again as long as I did not have t..."
"We just finished our 4 day vacation there for the 2nd year in a row. In 2 years we have stayed at this hotel 3 times. Overall great hotel, amazing location, great staff. Hotel cleanliness itself is overall good. The rooms I need to say definitely need a major upgrade. Last year you did upgrade the cable and that was great. The overall room itself though needs upgrading. The bathrooms look v..."
Insider Tips
💡 Pro Tip: The Neighborhood Village
Many guests don't discover until late in their stay that there's a "Neighborhood Village" nearby with restaurants, mini golf, bike rentals, and a nature center. It's accessible via a 5-minute walking path or the resort's free shuttle. Ask about it at check-in!
Best Time to Visit
Peak Season (March-May, Oct-Nov): Best weather but highest prices. Book 2-3 months ahead.
Summer (June-Aug): Hot and humid but great for families. Watch for afternoon storms.
Off-Season (Dec-Feb): Lower rates and fewer crowds. Some amenities may have reduced hours.
Room Selection Tips
- Ocean view rooms are worth the upgrade for the sunrise views
- Higher floors tend to have less noise from neighboring rooms
- Request a room away from elevators if you're a light sleeper
- Ask about recent renovations – some room sections are newer than others
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to Book Amelia Hotel at the Beach?
Compare prices and find the best available rates for your dates
More Amelia Island Hotels
Comparing options? Check out our other hotel guides:
- The Ritz-Carlton Amelia Island – Luxury beachfront resort
- All Amelia Island Hotels – Complete directory
- Fernandina Beach Hotels – Downtown options